|
Go 
|
New 
|
Find 
|
Notify 
|
|
Reply 
|
|
Admin 
|
New PM! 
|
Freshman

 |
Ok I may be stupid here, I know film is 24 frames a second and Video NCST is 30... But does turning a video signal to 24 frames a second actually make it look like film? Or does it just make it choppier?
|
| |
|
Senior

|
quote: Originally posted by HBKDinobot: does turning a video signal to 24 frames a second actually make it look like film? Or does it just make it choppier?
Well, according to the article *advertisement* about the new version of Magic Bullet in the new issue of American Cinematographer it does. They sort of dance the issue about whether the motion is actually more film like, or whether it just reproduces the 3:2 pulldown artifact (Which I've never even really noticed). This is of course in reference to to doing a 2:3 conversion to 24p and then going back through a 3:2 to 29.97. Here's the physics of it though. An object moving at a given speed will go farther in 1/48th of a second (Normal exposure at 24fps) than at 1/60th of a second (Normal at 60i or 30fps). By simply removing selected half frames the motion blur expressed on the frame is not elongated to compensate. Now, the program may have other features to achieve this and also deals with some of the other discrepancies. Of course, film shot at 30fps still looks like film, so make of that what you will as well. Nota "Half the frame he used to be" Mono
|
| |
| Posts: 665 | Location: Los Angeles, Ca. U.S.A. | Registered: October 31, 2002 |    |
|
Alumnus

|
I've used Cinelook. It's okay, not great. I've used magic bullet. It's much better. It too will let you do a 3:2 pull down, and the frames are much sharper than a standard "deinterlace" because it uses some crazy smart field blending technology. Plus, all you have to do is set your after effects timeline to your desired frame rate and pull the "trigger" and your footage is bulleted. [on soap box] Whatever "film look" plugin you use, please, please, don't do a 3:2 pull down treatment on footage that has fades and dissolves already in it. It drives me crazy when I'm watching something and halfway through a dissolve, the dissolve reverses for a frame. Add your dissolves after the 3:2 pull down. Personally, I don't like this effect at all, though. [off soap box]
Magic Bullet also has a "look suite" that has some really great film looks (I think this is more valuable than magic bullet itself). Educational version is $500 and you need AE 5.5, I think. I don't work for the Orphanage and I paid for my copy. Although I've achieved great results by creating my own "film look" treatments w/o expensive plugins, Cinelook, Magic Bullet and others are very helpful. regards, joren
|
| |
| Posts: 1742 | Location: HELL-A | Registered: March 05, 2003 |    |
|
 | Please Wait. Your request is being processed... |
© Studentfilms.com, Inc. 2008
|
|